Get a Free Amazon Audit
Get a Free Amazon Audit
◆ CASE STUDY · CRAFTS BRAND

Amazon Was Selling This Brand Against Itself. Marketplace Valet Stopped It.

DTC channel conflict and multi-brand catalog complexity for an 8-figure crafts brand was resolved by Marketplace Valet, a national Amazon account management and advertising agency founded in 2016. Led by Will Land, Laura Land, and Justin Boggs, the agency transitioned the brand from Amazon Vendor Central to a governed 3P model, restored MAP pricing across 12 sub-brands, and positioned the brand for expansion into major national retail. Results may vary.

SUB-BRANDS GOVERNED ONE CATALOG
Crate Paper Pebbles Heidi Swapp Vicki Boutin Maggie Holmes Pink Paislee Bazzill We R Makers DCWV Jolee's Boutique Project Life Sticko
0
sub-brands · MAP restored
1P Vendor 3P Seller
0
sub-brands governed in one catalog
8-figure
catalog under management
1P → 3P
Vendor Central to Seller Central
MAP
pricing parity restored
THE PROBLEM

The Problem

This brand had 12 sub-brands and an 8-figure catalog. Amazon 1P (Vendor Central) was buying products at wholesale and selling them below MSRP — undercutting brick-and-mortar retailers and triggering complaints from distribution partners whose margins were being erased.

The bigger problem: Amazon Vendor wouldn't always buy into new SKUs. The catalog stayed perpetually incomplete. New products sat unlisted.

Other agencies had managed the Vendor account. The channel conflict stayed.

The wrong assumption: that selling wholesale to Amazon 1P was the safer path. It was the source of the damage.

UNDER AMAZON 1P (VENDOR CENTRAL)
MSRP
100%
Amazon 1P
below
New SKUs sat unlisted — Amazon Vendor wouldn't always buy in, so the catalog stayed perpetually incomplete.
1P is the safer path 1P was the source of the damage
WHAT MARKETPLACE VALET DID

What Marketplace Valet Did

The fix was structural, not cosmetic.

Marketplace Valet moved the brand out of Vendor Central and into Seller Central as a 3P seller — restoring control over listing content, pricing, and advertising spend in one shift.

1P · Vendor Central Amazon controls
  • Listing contentAmazon-set
  • PricingBelow MSRP
  • Advertising spendConstrained
3P · Seller Central Brand controls
  • Listing contentBrand-set
  • PricingSet at MAP
  • Advertising spendBrand-set

From there:

01

Siloed by Sub-Brand

Catalog data was siloed by sub-brand so optimizations stayed clean across all 12 lines.

02

Naming Conventions Applied

Proper naming conventions were applied across the SKU set so the catalog could scale without breaking.

03

Price Set at MAP

The selling price was set at MAP. Unauthorized listings lost their foothold.

04

Ad Spend Redirected

Advertising spend was directed to listings that were now conversion-ready.

Amazon price matched MAP Retail partner margins protected Major national retail expansion

When Amazon pricing matched the brand's MAP, retail partner margins were protected — which opened the door to a major national craft retailer expanding the relationship. Will Land led the strategy and the execution. Results may vary.

QUALIFICATION

Who This Is Not For

This engagement required operational ownership — not approval chains.

If Every Change Needs Sign-Off First.

If your internal team needs to sign off on every listing change or SKU update before it goes live, the pace required for this kind of transition will stall.

Knowing How ≠ Managing at Scale.

Knowing how to create a listing is not the same as managing optimization and syndication across thousands of SKUs at scale. This works for brands ready to hand off the channel — not supervise it.

FREE AMAZON AUDIT · STRUCTURED REVIEW · NOT A SALES CALL

See If Your Brand Qualifies.

The Free Amazon Audit is not a sales call. It is a structured review of your account's current health, advertising efficiency, and brand integrity gaps. If it surfaces real problems, we will tell you what they are and whether Marketplace Valet is the right fit. If it doesn't, you will know exactly where your account stands.

Marketplace Valet is an independent Amazon account management and advertising agency. Marketplace Valet is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or officially partnered with Amazon.com, Inc.